Difference between revisions of "Category:1924, Top Films"

From 4 Enoch: : The Online Encyclopedia of Second Temple Judaism, and Christian and Islamic Origins
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Tag: Reverted
 
(30 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 4: Line 4:


-- -- '''1924, Top Films''' -- --
-- -- '''1924, Top Films''' -- --
>> [[:Category:Film Studies--1920s|Film Studies (1920s)]] <<


>> [[:Category:Film Studies--1920s|Film Studies (1920s)]] <<
>> [[:Category:Film Studies--1920s|Film Studies (1920s)]] <<
Line 11: Line 9:
[[:Category:1925, Top Films|1925]] -- [[:Category:1926, Top Films|1926]] -- [[:Category:1927, Top Films|1927]] -- [[:Category:1928, Top Films|1928]]  
[[:Category:1925, Top Films|1925]] -- [[:Category:1926, Top Films|1926]] -- [[:Category:1927, Top Films|1927]] -- [[:Category:1928, Top Films|1928]]  


 
-
[[File:1924 Keaton (film).jpg|thumb|left|152px]]
[[File:1924 Keaton (film).jpg|thumb|left|152px]]
[[File:1924 Stroheim (film).jpg|thumb|155px]]
[[File:1924 Stroheim (film).jpg|thumb|155px]]
Line 25: Line 23:
</gallery>
</gallery>


 
-
== My Ranking ==
 
==== -> -> -> ====
 
* #1. '''''Sherlock Jr.''''' <YouTube>
* #1. '''''Sherlock Jr.''''' <YouTube>
* #2. '''''The Last Laugh'''''
* #2. '''''The Last Laugh'''''
* #4. '''''Greed'''''
* #4. '''''Greed'''''
==== -> -> ====
* #6. '''''The Navigator (USA 1924 Keaton)'''''
* #6. '''''The Navigator (USA 1924 Keaton)'''''
* #7. '''''Die Nibelungen Part I'''''
* #7. '''''Die Nibelungen Part I'''''
Line 45: Line 36:
* #24. '''''Peter Pan''''' <YouTube>
* #24. '''''Peter Pan''''' <YouTube>
* #50+. '''''The Sea Hawk''''' <YouTube>
* #50+. '''''The Sea Hawk''''' <YouTube>
-


==== -> ====
=== Notable Mention ===
.
<gallery>
1924 Leger (film).jpg
1924 Clair (film).jpg
1924 Wiene (film).jpg
1924 Dreyer (film).png
1924 Protazanov (film).jpg
1924 Ponting (doc).jpg
1924 Lubitsch (film).jpg
1924 Breslauer (film).jpg
</gallery>
.
* #3. '''Le Ballet mecanique''' (Leger)
* #5. '''Entr'act''' (Clair)
* #9b. '''The Hands of Orlac'' (Wiene)
* #13. '''''Michael / Mikaël (Dreyer)'''''
* #15. '''''Aelita''''' (Protazanov)
* #16. The Great White Silence (Ponting)
* #17. The Marriage Circle (Lubitsch)
* #18. '''''Girl Sky (USA 1924 Newmeyer / Taylor)
* #21. Tha Saga of Gosta Bering
* #--. '''''The City Without Jews (Breslauer)''''
.


* #50+. ''Captain January'' (?)
=== Additional Films ===


* '''''Girl Sky (USA 1924 Newmeyer / Taylor)
-
 
<gallery>
* '''''[The] Joyless Street / Die Freudlose Gasse (DEU 1924 Pabst)'''''
1924 Cline (film) 2.jpg
1924 Cline (film).jpg
1924 Griffith (film).jpg
1924 Mercanton (film).jpg
1924 Noa (film).jpg
1924 Rosen (film).jpg
1924 Schertzinger (film).jpg
</gallery>
-


==== = ====
* #50+. '''''Captain January (Cline)''''' (?)
* #50+. '''''The Good Bad Boy (Cline)''''' (?)
* '''''America''''' (Griffith)
* '''''The Two Boys''''' (Mercanton)
* '''''Helen of Troy''''' (Noa)
* '''''Abraham Lincoln''''' (Rosen)
* '''''A Boy of Flanders''''' (Schertzinger)


== Critical Reception ==
== Critical Reception (1924) ==


==== '''[[MUBI, Best Films]]''' ====
=== '''[[MUBI, Best Films]]''' ===
* [https://mubi.com/lists/mubi-s-top-50-films-of-1924 50 Top Films of 1924]
* [https://mubi.com/lists/mubi-s-top-50-films-of-1924 50 Top Films of 1924]


-- #1. '''Sherlock Jr.'''  
-- #1. * '''Sherlock Jr.'''  
-- #2. '''The Last Laugh'''
-- #2. * '''The Last Laugh'''
-- #3. '''Le Ballet mecanique'''
-- #3. * '''Le Ballet mecanique'''
-- #4. '''Greed'''
-- #4. * '''Greed'''
-- #5. '''Entr'acte'''
-- #5. * '''Entr'acte'''
-- #6. '''The Navigator'''
-- #6. '''The Navigator'''
-- #7. '''Die Nibelungen Part I'''
-- #7. * '''Die Nibelungen Part I'''
-- #8. '''The Thief of Bagdad'''
-- #8. '''The Thief of Bagdad'''
-- #9. Cartoon Factory
-- #9. <Cartoon Factory>
-- #9b. '''The Hands of Orlac''' (listed in 1925)
-- #10. '''Die Nibelungen Part II'''
-- #10. '''Die Nibelungen Part II'''


-- #11. Symphonie diagonale
-- #11. <Symphonie diagonale>
-- #12. '''He Who Gets Slapped'''
-- #12. '''He Who Gets Slapped'''
-- #13. '''Michael / Mikaël '''
-- #13. '''Michael / Mikaël '''
Line 83: Line 113:
-- #20. '''The Iron Horse'''
-- #20. '''The Iron Horse'''
-- #21. '''The Saga of Gosta Berling'''
-- #21. '''The Saga of Gosta Berling'''
-- #22. Opus III
-- #22. <Opus III>
-- #23. The Epic of Everest
-- #23. <The Epic of Everest>
-- #24. '''Peter Pan'''
-- #24. '''Peter Pan'''
-- #25. '''Waxworks'''
-- #25. '''Waxworks'''
-- #26. '''The Extraordinary Adventures of Mr. West'''
-- #26. '''The Extraordinary Adventures of Mr. West'''
-- #27. Help!
-- #27. <Help!>
-- #28. The Beauty from Nivernais
-- #28. <The Beauty from Nivernais>
-- #29. The Cigarette Girl of Mosselprom
-- #29. <The Cigarette Girl of Mosselprom>
-- #30. Forbidden Paradise
-- #30. <Forbidden Paradise>


-- #31. The Lion of the Moguls
-- #31. The Lion of the Moguls
-- #32. The Finances of the Grand Duke
-- #32. ''The Finances of the Grand Duke''
-- #33. The White Shadow
-- #33. The White Shadow
-- #34. Soviet Toys
-- #34. <Soviet Toys>
-- #35. Interplanetary Revolution
-- #35. Interplanetary Revolution
-- #36. Cloud Phenomena of Maloja
-- #36. Cloud Phenomena of Maloja
-- #37. New Year's Eve
-- #37. New Year's Eve
-- #38. The Fugitive Futurist
-- #38. <The Fugitive Futurist>
-- #39. Looney Lens: Tenth Avenue, NYC
-- #39. Looney Lens: Tenth Avenue, NYC
-- #40. '''Isn't Life Wonderful'''
-- #40. '''Isn't Life Wonderful'''
Line 111: Line 141:
-- #47. '''Thundering Hoofs'''
-- #47. '''Thundering Hoofs'''
-- #48. The Average Woman
-- #48. The Average Woman
-- #49. Feet of Mud
-- #49. * Feet of Mud
-- #50. Iceland Fishermen
-- #50. Iceland Fishermen


==== Silent Era, Best Films ====
=== [https://www.flickchart.com/Charts.aspx?year=1919 Flickchart, Best Films] ===
 
-- #1. '''Sherlock Jr.''' (Keaton)
-- #2. '''The Last Laugh''' 
-- #3. '''Greed''' (Stroheim)
-- #4. '''The Navigator'''
-- #5. '''Die Nibelungen: Siegfried''' (Lang)
-- #6. '''The Thief of Bagdad'''
-- #7. ''Girl Shy''
-- #8. '''He Who Gets Slapped''' (Sjostrom)
-- #9. '''Die Nibelungen: Krimhild's Revenge''' (Lang)
-- #10. The Hands of Orlac [Orlacs Hande] (Wiene)
 
-- #11. '''The Iron Horse''' (Ford)
-- #12. ** Le Ballet mecanique
-- #13. ''Entr'act'' (Clair)
-- #14. * Waxworks (Leni)
-- #15. ''Michael'' (Dreyer)
-- #16. '''Peter Pan'''
-- #17. ''The Great White Silence''
-- #18. ''America''
-- #19. ''Aelita''
-- #20. ''The Marriage Circle''
 
-- #21. <The Last Man on Earth>
-- #22. ''The Finances of the Grand Duke''
-- #23. Trip to Mars
-- #24. ''Kino-Eye''
-- #25. Hot Water
-- #26. Picking peaches
-- #27. ''The Saga of Gosta Berling''
-- #28. Her Night of Romance
-- #29. Sawdust Trail
-- #30. Barbara Fritchie
 
-- #44. <The Cartoon Factory>
-- #53. The Sea Hawk (Lloyd)
-- #62. Captain January (Cline)
-- #72. <Help!>
-- #76. <Symphonie diagonale>
-- #83. <Soviet Toys>
 
=== History of Cinema, Best Films ===
 
-- #1. ** Sherlock Jr. (Keaton)
-- #2. ** The Last Laugh 
-- #3. ** Le Ballet mecanique
-- #4. ** Greed (Stroheim)
-- #5. ** Entr'act (Clair)
-- #7. ** Die Nibelungen (Lang)
 
-- #12. * He Who Gets Slapped (Sjostrom)
-- #13. * Michael (Dreyer)
-- #15. * Aelita
-- #16. * The Great White Silence
-- #17. * The Marriage Circle
-- #18. * Girl Shy
-- #19. * L'inhumaine (L'Herbier)
-- #20. * The Iron Horse (Ford)
 
-- #21. * The Saga of Gosta Berling [Gosta Berlings Saga]
-- #24. * Peter Pan
-- #25. * Waxworks (Leni)
-- #49. * Feet of Mud (Edwards)
 
-- Backbiters [Catherine; ou, Una vie sans joie] (Renoir)
-- The Hands of Orlac [Orlacs Hande] (Wiene)
 
=== Silent Era, Best Films ===


-- #10. '''Greed'''
-- #10. '''Greed'''
Line 136: Line 234:
-- #206. ''Isn’t Life Wonderful?''
-- #206. ''Isn’t Life Wonderful?''
-- #208. ''Gosta Berling’s Saga''
-- #208. ''Gosta Berling’s Saga''
-- #236. ''The Extraordinary Adventures of
-- #236. ''The Extraordinary Adventures of Mr. West in the Land of the Bolsheviks''
Mr. West in the Land of the Bolsheviks''
-- #237. ''Mikaël''
-- #237. ''Mikaël''
-- #238. ''The Open Road''
-- #238. ''The Open Road''
Line 155: Line 252:
-- ''Thundering Hoofs''
-- ''Thundering Hoofs''


==== Paste Magazine, Best Films ====
=== Paste Magazine, Best Films ===


-- #1. 1.Sherlock, Jr. (Keaton)
-- #1. '''Sherlock, Jr.''' (Keaton)
-- #9. He Who Gets Slapped (Sjostrom)
-- #9. He Who Gets Slapped (Sjostrom)
-- #28. Greed (Stroheim)
-- #28. Greed (Stroheim)
-- #50. The Navigator (Keaton)
-- #50. The Navigator (Keaton)
-- #55. Ther Last Laugh (Murnau)
-- #55. The Last Laugh (Murnau)
-- #59. The Great White Silence (Ponting)
-- #59. ''The Great White Silence'' (Ponting)
-- #63. The Thief of Bagdad (Walsh)
-- #63. The Thief of Bagdad (Walsh)
-- #75. Gösta Berlings saga / The Saga of Gosta Berling (Stiller)
-- #75. Gösta Berlings saga / The Saga of Gosta Berling (Stiller)


==== '''[[Schneider, Best Films]]''' ====
=== '''[[Schneider, Best Films]]''' ===


-- #1. '''''Sherlock Jr.'''''
-- #1. '''''Sherlock Jr.'''''
Line 173: Line 270:
-- #8. '''''The Thief of Bagdad'''''  
-- #8. '''''The Thief of Bagdad'''''  


==== '''[[National Film Registry]]''' ====
=== '''[[National Film Registry]]''' ===


-- #1. '''''Sherlock Jr.'''''  
-- #1. '''''Sherlock Jr.'''''  
Line 186: Line 283:
-- Reverend Solomon Sir Jones films <doc>  
-- Reverend Solomon Sir Jones films <doc>  


==== '''[[TSPDT, Best Films]]''' ====  
=== '''[[TSPDT, Best Films]]''' ===  


-- #1. '''''Sherlock Jr.'''''  
-- #1. '''Sherlock Jr.'''''  
-- #2. '''''The Last Laugh'''''
-- #2. '''The Last Laugh'''''
-- #4. '''''Greed'''''
-- #4. '''''Greed'''''
-- #6.'''''The Navigator'''''  
-- #6.'''''The Navigator'''''  


==== '''[[Top10ner, Best Films]]''' ====  
=== '''[[Top10ner, Best Films]]''' ===  


-- #1. '''''Sherlock Jr.'''''  
-- #1. '''''Sherlock Jr.'''''  
Line 200: Line 297:
-- #6. '''''The Navigator'''''
-- #6. '''''The Navigator'''''


==== '''[[Film101, Best Films]]''' ====  
=== '''[[Film101, Best Films]]''' ===  


-- #1. '''''Sherlock Jr.'''''  
-- #1. '''''Sherlock Jr.'''''  
Line 208: Line 305:
-- #8. '''''The Thief of Bagdad'''''
-- #8. '''''The Thief of Bagdad'''''


==== '''[[Rotten Tomatoes, Best Films]]''' ====
=== '''[[Rotten Tomatoes, Best Films]]''' ===


-- #2. '''''The Last Laugh'''''
-- #2. '''''The Last Laugh'''''
-- #6. '''''The Navigator'''''
-- #6. '''''The Navigator'''''


==== '''[[ChildActors, Best Films]]''' ====  
=== '''[[ChildActors, Best Films]]''' ===  


-- #14. '''''Kino Eye''''' (URSS)  
-- #14. '''''Kino Eye''''' (URSS)  
Line 230: Line 327:
-- A Self-Made Failure <lost>
-- A Self-Made Failure <lost>


==== '''[[Best International Films]]''' ====  
==='''[[Best International Films]]''' ===
{Russian}
{Russian}
-- ''Aelita''
-- ''Aelita''

Latest revision as of 07:31, 14 September 2024

1924 Murnau (film).jpg

1920 -- 1921 -- 1922 -- 1923

-- -- 1924, Top Films -- --

>> Film Studies (1920s) <<

1925 -- 1926 -- 1927 -- 1928

-

1924 Keaton (film).jpg
1924 Stroheim (film).jpg

-

  • #1. Sherlock Jr. <YouTube>
  • #2. The Last Laugh
  • #4. Greed
  • #6. The Navigator (USA 1924 Keaton)
  • #7. Die Nibelungen Part I
  • #8. The Thief of Bagdad <YouTube>
  • #10. Die Nibelungen Part II
  • #12. He Who Gets Slapped <YouTube>
  • #14. Kino Eye
  • #20. The Iron Horse <YouTube>
  • #24. Peter Pan <YouTube>
  • #50+. The Sea Hawk <YouTube>

-

Notable Mention

.

.

  • #3. Le Ballet mecanique (Leger)
  • #5. Entr'act (Clair)
  • #9b. 'The Hands of Orlac (Wiene)
  • #13. Michael / Mikaël (Dreyer)
  • #15. Aelita (Protazanov)
  • #16. The Great White Silence (Ponting)
  • #17. The Marriage Circle (Lubitsch)
  • #18. Girl Sky (USA 1924 Newmeyer / Taylor)
  • #21. Tha Saga of Gosta Bering
  • #--. The City Without Jews (Breslauer)'

.

Additional Films

-

-

  • #50+. Captain January (Cline) (?)
  • #50+. The Good Bad Boy (Cline) (?)
  • America (Griffith)
  • The Two Boys (Mercanton)
  • Helen of Troy (Noa)
  • Abraham Lincoln (Rosen)
  • A Boy of Flanders (Schertzinger)

Critical Reception (1924)

MUBI, Best Films

-- #1. * Sherlock Jr. -- #2. * The Last Laugh -- #3. * Le Ballet mecanique -- #4. * Greed -- #5. * Entr'acte -- #6. The Navigator -- #7. * Die Nibelungen Part I -- #8. The Thief of Bagdad -- #9. <Cartoon Factory> -- #9b. The Hands of Orlac (listed in 1925) -- #10. Die Nibelungen Part II

-- #11. <Symphonie diagonale> -- #12. He Who Gets Slapped -- #13. Michael / Mikaël -- #14. Kino Eye -- #15. Aelita -- #16. The Great White Silence -- #17. The Marriage Circle -- #18. Girl Shy -- #19. L'inhumaine -- #20. The Iron Horse -- #21. The Saga of Gosta Berling -- #22. <Opus III> -- #23. <The Epic of Everest> -- #24. Peter Pan -- #25. Waxworks -- #26. The Extraordinary Adventures of Mr. West -- #27. <Help!> -- #28. <The Beauty from Nivernais> -- #29. <The Cigarette Girl of Mosselprom> -- #30. <Forbidden Paradise>

-- #31. The Lion of the Moguls -- #32. The Finances of the Grand Duke -- #33. The White Shadow -- #34. <Soviet Toys> -- #35. Interplanetary Revolution -- #36. Cloud Phenomena of Maloja -- #37. New Year's Eve -- #38. <The Fugitive Futurist> -- #39. Looney Lens: Tenth Avenue, NYC -- #40. Isn't Life Wonderful -- #41. The Flood -- #42. Her Night of Romance -- #43. America -- #44. The Enchanted Cottage -- #45. Barbara Frietchie -- #46. Conductor 1492 -- #47. Thundering Hoofs -- #48. The Average Woman -- #49. * Feet of Mud -- #50. Iceland Fishermen

Flickchart, Best Films

-- #1. Sherlock Jr. (Keaton) -- #2. The Last Laugh -- #3. Greed (Stroheim) -- #4. The Navigator -- #5. Die Nibelungen: Siegfried (Lang) -- #6. The Thief of Bagdad -- #7. Girl Shy -- #8. He Who Gets Slapped (Sjostrom) -- #9. Die Nibelungen: Krimhild's Revenge (Lang) -- #10. The Hands of Orlac [Orlacs Hande] (Wiene)

-- #11. The Iron Horse (Ford) -- #12. ** Le Ballet mecanique -- #13. Entr'act (Clair) -- #14. * Waxworks (Leni) -- #15. Michael (Dreyer) -- #16. Peter Pan -- #17. The Great White Silence -- #18. America -- #19. Aelita -- #20. The Marriage Circle

-- #21. <The Last Man on Earth> -- #22. The Finances of the Grand Duke -- #23. Trip to Mars -- #24. Kino-Eye -- #25. Hot Water -- #26. Picking peaches -- #27. The Saga of Gosta Berling -- #28. Her Night of Romance -- #29. Sawdust Trail -- #30. Barbara Fritchie

-- #44. <The Cartoon Factory> -- #53. The Sea Hawk (Lloyd) -- #62. Captain January (Cline) -- #72. <Help!> -- #76. <Symphonie diagonale> -- #83. <Soviet Toys>

History of Cinema, Best Films

-- #1. ** Sherlock Jr. (Keaton) -- #2. ** The Last Laugh -- #3. ** Le Ballet mecanique -- #4. ** Greed (Stroheim) -- #5. ** Entr'act (Clair) -- #7. ** Die Nibelungen (Lang)

-- #12. * He Who Gets Slapped (Sjostrom) -- #13. * Michael (Dreyer) -- #15. * Aelita -- #16. * The Great White Silence -- #17. * The Marriage Circle -- #18. * Girl Shy -- #19. * L'inhumaine (L'Herbier) -- #20. * The Iron Horse (Ford)

-- #21. * The Saga of Gosta Berling [Gosta Berlings Saga] -- #24. * Peter Pan -- #25. * Waxworks (Leni) -- #49. * Feet of Mud (Edwards)

-- Backbiters [Catherine; ou, Una vie sans joie] (Renoir) -- The Hands of Orlac [Orlacs Hande] (Wiene)

Silent Era, Best Films

-- #10. Greed -- #17. Sherlock Jr. -- #22. The Last Laugh -- #26. The Thief of Bagdad -- #45. Die Nibelungen -- #49. He Who Gets Slapped -- #50. Girl Shy -- #59. The Navigator -- #80. Strike -- #97. The Iron Horse

-- #104. Aelita -- #131. The Marriage Circle -- #153. Waxworks -- #166. The Sea Hawk -- #168. Entr’acte -- #175. Peter Pan -- #181. Hot Water -- #206. Isn’t Life Wonderful? -- #208. Gosta Berling’s Saga -- #236. The Extraordinary Adventures of Mr. West in the Land of the Bolsheviks -- #237. Mikaël -- #238. The Open Road -- #255. Le Ballet méchanique

-- #300+. America -- Changing Husbands -- The Chechachos -- Helen’s Babies -- L’Inhumaine -- Kino-Eye -- Manhandled -- Open All Night -- The Crazy Ray -- Romola -- Smouldering Fires -- Thundering Hoofs

Paste Magazine, Best Films

-- #1. Sherlock, Jr. (Keaton) -- #9. He Who Gets Slapped (Sjostrom) -- #28. Greed (Stroheim) -- #50. The Navigator (Keaton) -- #55. The Last Laugh (Murnau) -- #59. The Great White Silence (Ponting) -- #63. The Thief of Bagdad (Walsh) -- #75. Gösta Berlings saga / The Saga of Gosta Berling (Stiller)

Schneider, Best Films

-- #1. Sherlock Jr. -- #2. The Last Laugh -- #4. Greed -- #8. The Thief of Bagdad

National Film Registry

-- #1. Sherlock Jr. -- #4. Greed -- #6. The Navigator -- #8. The Thief of Bagdad -- #12. He Who Gets Slapped -- #20. The Iron Horse -- #24. Peter Pan

-- The Chechahcos -- Reverend Solomon Sir Jones films <doc>

TSPDT, Best Films

-- #1. Sherlock Jr. -- #2. The Last Laugh -- #4. Greed -- #6.The Navigator

Top10ner, Best Films

-- #1. Sherlock Jr. -- #2. The Last Laugh -- #4. Greed -- #6. The Navigator

Film101, Best Films

-- #1. Sherlock Jr. -- #2. The Last Laugh -- #4. Greed -- #6. The Navigator -- #8. The Thief of Bagdad

Rotten Tomatoes, Best Films

-- #2. The Last Laugh -- #6. The Navigator

ChildActors, Best Films

-- #14. Kino Eye (URSS) -- #24. Peter Pan

-- A Boy of Flanders -- Les deux gosses (France) -- The Good Bad Boy -- Captain January

-- Daddies -- The Family Secret -- Helen's Babies -- Our Gang: High Society -- Little Robinson Crusoe -- A Self-Made Failure <lost>

Best International Films

{Russian} -- Aelita

Intenet

Tubi

-- The Iron Horse -- Sherlock Jr.

-- The Hands of Orlac -- Branded a Bandit

Media in category "1924, Top Films"

The following 27 files are in this category, out of 27 total.