Difference between revisions of "(+) Paul and His Interpreters: A Critical History = Geschichte der Paulinischen Forschung (1912 Schweitzer / Montgomery), book (English ed.)"

From 4 Enoch: : The Online Encyclopedia of Second Temple Judaism, and Christian and Islamic Origins
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(14 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
<bibexternal title="Paul and His Interpreters" author="Schweitzer"/>
''' Paul and His Interpreters: A Critical History''' (1912) is the English edition of [[Geschichte der Paulinischen Forschung (1911 Schweitzer), book]]. Translated from the German by [[William Montgomery]].
''' Paul and His Interpreters: A Critical History''' (1912) is the English edition of [[Geschichte der Paulinischen Forschung (1911 Schweitzer), book]]. Translated from the German by [[William Montgomery]].


==Abstract==
==Abstract==


Schweitzer’s critique of a century of German scholarship on the Apostle Paul.  Schweitzer attacks the Tübingen school, founded by F. C. Baur, for its insistence that Paul’s theology was Hellenistic in orientation, usually leaning heavily upon the Greco-Roman mystery cults.  Schweitzer insisted that Paul must be interpreted independently of the Synoptics, John, and the rest of the New Testament writings.  Schweitzer faults the interpreters of Paul for finding the man that they wanted to find.  He made the same judgment of nineteenth century Jesus historians in ''The Quest of the Historical Jesus'' (1906).  The tone of this first volume on Paul is critical and historical; Schweitzer’s own ideas are kept in the background and often remain unwritten except perhaps in the concluding chapter (“Summing-Up and Formulation of the Problem”).  Schweitzer presented a fuller theology of Paul in his 1931 text ''The Mysticism of Paul the Apostle''. The earlier text remains a valuable resource for nineteenth century German historiography on Paul.   - '''Ronald Ruark''', University of Michigan
Schweitzer’s critique of a century of German scholarship on the Apostle Paul.  Schweitzer attacks the Tübingen school, founded by [[Ferdinand Christian Baur]], for its insistence that Paul’s theology was Hellenistic in orientation, usually leaning heavily upon the Greco-Roman mystery cults.  Schweitzer insisted that Paul must be interpreted independently of the Synoptics, John, and the rest of the New Testament writings.  Schweitzer faults the interpreters of Paul for finding the man that they wanted to find.  He made the same judgment of nineteenth century Jesus historians in his [[Von Reimarus zu Wrede (1906 Schweitzer), book]].  The tone of this first volume on Paul is critical and historical; Schweitzer’s own ideas are kept in the background and often remain unwritten except perhaps in the concluding chapter (“Summing-Up and Formulation of the Problem”).  Schweitzer presented a fuller theology of Paul in his 1930 text, [[Die Mystik des Apostels Paulus (1930 Schweitzer), book]]. The earlier text remains a valuable resource for nineteenth century German historiography on Paul. -- '''Ronald Ruark''', University of Michigan


==Editions==
==Editions==
Line 28: Line 29:
[http://books.google.com/books?id=YF8JAQAAIAAJ&q=Paul+and+His+Interpreters&dq=Paul+and+His+Interpreters&cd=1 Google Books]
[http://books.google.com/books?id=YF8JAQAAIAAJ&q=Paul+and+His+Interpreters&dq=Paul+and+His+Interpreters&cd=1 Google Books]
[[Category:Scholarship]]
 
[[Category:Books|1912 Schweitzer]]
 
[[Category:English language|1912 Schweitzer]]
[[Category:1912| Schweitzer]]
 
[[Category:Translations--1910s|1912 Schweitzer]]
[[Category:Translated from German|1912 Schweitzer]]
[[Category:Translated from German|1912 Schweitzer]]
[[Category:Translated into English|1912 Schweitzer]]
 
[[Category:German to English|1912 Schweitzer]]  
[[Category:English language--1910s|1912 Schweitzer]]
[[Category:Made in the 1910s|1912 Schweitzer]]
 
[[Category:Paul of Tarsus (subject)|1912 Schweitzer]]
[[Category:Pauline Studies--1910s|1912 Schweitzer]]
[[Category:Pauline Studies--English|1912 Schweitzer]]
 
[[Category:Reception History--1910s|1912 Schweitzer]]
[[Category:Reception History--English|1912 Schweitzer]]
 
[[Category:Paul, Reception History (subject)|1912 Schweitzer]]
 
[[Category:History of fiction (subject)|1912 Schweitzer]]
 
[[Category:Top 1910s|1912 Schweitzer]]

Latest revision as of 11:10, 30 September 2023

<bibexternal title="Paul and His Interpreters" author="Schweitzer"/> Paul and His Interpreters: A Critical History (1912) is the English edition of Geschichte der Paulinischen Forschung (1911 Schweitzer), book. Translated from the German by William Montgomery.

Abstract

Schweitzer’s critique of a century of German scholarship on the Apostle Paul. Schweitzer attacks the Tübingen school, founded by Ferdinand Christian Baur, for its insistence that Paul’s theology was Hellenistic in orientation, usually leaning heavily upon the Greco-Roman mystery cults. Schweitzer insisted that Paul must be interpreted independently of the Synoptics, John, and the rest of the New Testament writings. Schweitzer faults the interpreters of Paul for finding the man that they wanted to find. He made the same judgment of nineteenth century Jesus historians in his Von Reimarus zu Wrede (1906 Schweitzer), book. The tone of this first volume on Paul is critical and historical; Schweitzer’s own ideas are kept in the background and often remain unwritten except perhaps in the concluding chapter (“Summing-Up and Formulation of the Problem”). Schweitzer presented a fuller theology of Paul in his 1930 text, Die Mystik des Apostels Paulus (1930 Schweitzer), book. The earlier text remains a valuable resource for nineteenth century German historiography on Paul. -- Ronald Ruark, University of Michigan

Editions

Published in London [England]: Black, 1912. Reprinted in 1956 and 2004.

Table of contents

  • Chapter 1 – The Beginnings of the Scientific Method
  • Chapter 2 – Baur and His Critics
  • Chapter 3 – From Baur to Holtzmann
  • Chapter 4 – H.J. Holtzmann
  • Chapter 5 – Critical Questions and Hypotheses
  • Chapter 6 – The Position at the Beginning of the Twentieth Century
  • Chapter 7 – Paulinism and Comparative Religion
  • Chapter 8 – Summing-up and Formulation of the Problem

External links

Google Books